Sunday, 30 November 2014

Paul McCartney Waistcoat and Granny Square Science

Hello! And welcome to the first post of my new blog!

My son, having a very cool sense of style, a fan of the Beatles and most things 60s, has commissioned me to make this wonderfully retro and kitsch granny square waistcoat, as worn by Paul McCartney in the filming of A Magical Mystery Tour back in 1967.

Photo by Nigel Jarvis, 1967. Published by Daily Mail.
Very apt that my first post should be about the humble but iconic granny square, since it was one of the very first things I made when I learned how to crochet with my mum, only about 4 or 5 years after the photo of Macca was taken, I imagine. It's very possible he was still wearing the waistcoat back then when me and my mum were busy making that granny square blanket together!

So over to google I went to see if anyone else had tried to replicate the waistcoat and found a wonderful blog by Amjaylou who had done just that. Some beautifully detailed information on how she had made her fabulous version of the waistcoat after extensive research, from the assembly of photos to choosing of the yarn right down to the assembly. I also found a pattern by Vintage Visage, so I downloaded that too in my usual manner of leaving no stone unturned. This one differs slightly from Amjaylou's in that there are 3 squares instead of 2 at either side on the top front, and it's a little shorter. In both of these respects it's probably closer to the original design, though both are beautiful in their own right and Amjaylou's version is perhaps a more modern update of the original!

Having looked around at different yarn possibilities (the original waistcoat having been made from 4-ply (fingering weight) yarn), and eventually resigned myself to the fact that exact colour matches would be pretty much impossible, I decided to go with the Drops Baby Merino from Wool Warehouse as used by Amjaylou. The colours I chose are a little different from hers though...from the top, one ball each of light yellow, lime, vibrant green, light sky blue, lavender, electric blue, navy blue, old pink, heather, red and orange. 5 balls of grey for joining.

All in all I'm pretty pleased with my choice. There's a good balance of light, medium and dark. I've left out both the very pastel pinks and the vibrant pink because pink in general is really not my thing. But I couldn't resist the 'old pink' which I think tones in very well, and I do believe there's some pink in Macca's original. The grey I'm using for joining (same as Amjaylou's) is exactly the colour of school socks! Normally I'm very unconfident at putting colours together, but these seem to work well to my eyes. Perhaps the range is designed so that all the colours in it will go well together. Or, I don't know, maybe it was luck. But hey, who cares, I love it! And oh, this yarn is so LUSH. It's such a treat to work with after so much acrylic in recent projects.

Now down to the building block itself- the actual granny square. It's such a simple little thing but SO many different variations of the pattern exist. A little experimentation was called for. I tried the version of the square that's very commonly used- with 2 chains in the corner spaces and one between the treble clusters on the sides. Then I made one with absolutely NO chain spaces at all, even in the corners- just for the heck of it and to see what would happen. Here they are- same yarn and hook (2.5mm), the only difference is the leaving out of those chain spaces on the one on the right.

I was absolutely fascinated that the act of leaving out the chains could cause such a dramatic difference in size (should I get out more? Haha...), though I suppose it's obvious when you think about it. And in the end I really liked the smaller square. It's so dinky and neat, and slightly more 'rigid' than the one on the right, with smaller holes. I somehow felt it to be more appropriate for a man's waistcoat. So... the small square it is. And I'm going with the Vintage Visage pattern in terms of assembling the squares, as it will fit the gauge of the smaller ones. Also I just love the fact that the squares will be assembled exactly the same as Macca's. Nerdy, I am.

I decided to make a little sample swatch of 4 squares to see what they would be like for joining. I soon discovered that the lack of chains in the corners was going to be a problem. The so-called corners would not even touch each other. So I undid they final grey rounds of each square and chained 2 in the corners- in the outer round only, I left the rest as it was. MUCH better. I also tried different joining methods. Amjaylou used join-as-you-go and it looks wonderful. In the past I've joined motifs by sewing together the back loops only, as in this project and also in this one (technique described excellently by Bunny Mummy). I decided that for my purposes neither of these methods would be appropriate, as they are quite stretchy (in fact they almost add in effect the equivalent of an extra row of stitches) and I'm worried they would make the overall size of the waistcoat too big. I decided joining both loops together by whip stitching (a much more 'solid' join) would be just the ticket. And probably how the original waistcoat would have been assembled? More authenticity to satisfy my inner nerd. Here's my sample swatch.

So yeah, quite happy with that.

Full steam ahead with the waistcoat now! Can I make it in time for Christmas? 114, it's going to be a challenge!


  1. Welcome to blogging!

    Everything old really is new again :P I'm very intrigued how just leaving out the chain spaces made such a difference to the size of your squares. Definitely have to try that on my next granny square project :)

    Take care,
    Michelle xx

    1. Hi Michelle, so lovely to hear from you. So excited to get my first comment!!!

  2. Good to see you in Blogland! :)

    Looking forward to see the finished project! You son will certainly love it.

    Take care

    1. Thank you Anne :-)
      By the way, I tried to look at your Crochet Between Worlds blog but it says it has been removed?

    2. Ahhh... I mispelled it... So did Michelle.

    3. Thank you, checking it out now :-)

    4. Oh dear, we are so clever. Sorry about that!

    5. Haha, mystery solved! I love your blog and the whole idea of a blog which crosses continents.

  3. Hello!
    Welcome to the wonderful world of blogging, and congrats on writing your first post. Thanks for your kind mention here - I'm so looking forward to seeing your finished waistcoat, and I'm intrigued to know how you work the three squares across the shoulder with only two on the back part of the shoulder. It had me stumped!
    I've worn mine quite a few times now and it always gets a lot of attention. I've been stopped many a time by people wanting to know more about it. I wore it to Yarndale recently, which you can read about here:-
    I bet it's going to look great on your son :-)
    Happy granny crocheting
    Amanda x

  4. Thanks Amanda! I'm absolutely loving making it and often look at yours for inspiration. I might just have to make one for myself at some point :-)

  5. Hi and congratulations on a lovely first post! Just love this garment .... I grew up with the Beatles, I think might have to make one for myself, it!s just so cool!

    1. Thanks Pat! Would love to see yours when it's finished :-) We all love the Beatles in our house.